Not to defend Noel Fylnn or anything but when he can’t rely on his umpires and he sees two players rolling around on the ground together he hasn’t much choice but send off the two lads! Poor organisation though as a whole from both Noel for not bringing any of his own officials and also Ballinamere for not stepping in to provide officialskaiserchief wrote:In this case the club didn't provide lines men neither, so their resources weren't used at all.Plain of the Herbs wrote:Just on this, the guideline (don't ask me if it's a bye-law or what it is) is that the referee brings his own umpires while the host club provides the linesmen. Of course, if the referee lands without an umpire, that just further stretches the resources of the host club.kaiserchief wrote:. . . Surely Ballinamere if hosting the game should have provided umpires for the referee.. .
Surely the referee if without umpires would know 1 or 2 hours before the game and should have to alert the host venue.
Umpires from the opposing team, calling ref's attention for an incident he didn't see is and worse again, the ref using that information to give a straight red card.
Wasn't at game but heard from a Drumcullen man that is twas pure madness from Noel Flynn.
Senior B Hurling 2018
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
-
- All Star
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 12:20 pm
- Club: birr
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
Host clubs should not have to provide umpires.
- Lone Shark
- All Star
- Posts: 5387
- Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 5:21 pm
- Club: Ferbane
- Location: Roscommon
- Contact:
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
Obviously in an ideal world, the ref would have his own - however nothing about club refereeing is ideal, since it's very hard get enough people involved and to make sure you have fit, competent officials at as many games as possible. And at least a referee can get a few bob out of it - I have genuinely no idea why anyone would become an umpire.greenairfield wrote:Host clubs should not have to provide umpires.
The question then becomes where do you get them from, and the host club is obviously one other option. It's certainly preferable to the "one form each club" nonsense you often get, where one fella waves a wide and the other signals a point regardless of whether the shot missed ball stop or bounced on the top of the crossbar on the way over.
Kevin Egan. Signed out of respect for players and all involved with Offaly.
-
- All Star
- Posts: 1126
- Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 4:09 pm
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
If a club wishes to host a game they should provide umpires, score board, showers etc. If they can't, they should not get games. Was at moystown, really will run with parking,stewards and scoreboard. Was also in kilurin. No scoreboard, no parking and they charging in to the game.
-
- All Star
- Posts: 444
- Joined: Tue Mar 26, 2013 4:49 pm
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
So you’re saying if the field has not got a scoreboard or parking they should not charge going into the game?private joker wrote:If a club wishes to host a game they should provide umpires, score board, showers etc. If they can't, they should not get games. Was at moystown, really will run with parking,stewards and scoreboard. Was also in kilurin. No scoreboard, no parking and they charging in to the game.
-
- All Star
- Posts: 1029
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 12:20 pm
- Club: birr
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
If a club has not got a scoreboard it this doesnt say much for the club
-
- All Star
- Posts: 991
- Joined: Tue Jun 27, 2017 11:31 am
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
In fairness, they do have TWO pitchesgreenairfield wrote:If a club has not got a scoreboard it this doesnt say much for the club
Good Luck
-
- All Star
- Posts: 1126
- Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 4:09 pm
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
A club when hosting a championship games should have a working scoreboard. If they don't, they should not get games. Parking can't be helped. But if I'm paying in to watch a match , I don't want to be wondering what the score is. If
-
- All Star
- Posts: 1126
- Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 4:09 pm
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
Also kilurin is too small for adult hurling.
-
- All Star
- Posts: 442
- Joined: Tue Mar 04, 2014 12:09 pm
- Club: town
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
I agree. Scoreboard should be a necessity if hosting a game.
-
- All Star
- Posts: 3511
- Joined: Sat Nov 27, 2004 4:47 pm
- Club: Lusmagh
Round 5 fixtures
Senior B fixtures nest weekend (including the two back matches):
Tuesday 24th July: Tullamore v Ballinamere at Bórd na Móna Park at 7.30pm
Tuesday 24th July: Brosna Gaels v Drumcullen at KIlcormac at 7.30pm
Saturday 28th July: Clodiagh Gaels v Brosna Gaels at Clara at 7.30pm
Saturday 28th July: Lusmagh v Shamrocks at Banagher at 7.30pm
Sunday 28th: Ballinamere v Carrig & Riverstown at Kinnitty at 12 noon
Sunday 28th July: Drumcullen v Tullamore at Kilcormac at 6.30pm.
Tuesday 24th July: Tullamore v Ballinamere at Bórd na Móna Park at 7.30pm
Tuesday 24th July: Brosna Gaels v Drumcullen at KIlcormac at 7.30pm
Saturday 28th July: Clodiagh Gaels v Brosna Gaels at Clara at 7.30pm
Saturday 28th July: Lusmagh v Shamrocks at Banagher at 7.30pm
Sunday 28th: Ballinamere v Carrig & Riverstown at Kinnitty at 12 noon
Sunday 28th July: Drumcullen v Tullamore at Kilcormac at 6.30pm.
Pat Donegan. Signed out of respect for players and all involved with Offaly.
Re: Round 5 fixtures
[quote="Plain of the Herbs"]Senior B fixtures nest weekend (including the two back matches):
Tuesday 24th July: Tullamore v Ballinamere at Bórd na Móna Park at 7.30pm - Tullamore by 5 points
Tuesday 24th July: Brosna Gaels v Drumcullen at KIlcormac at 7.30pm - Brosna Gaels by 3 points
Saturday 28th July: Clodiagh Gaels v Brosna Gaels at Clara at 7.30pm - Brosna Gaels by 1 point
Saturday 28th July: Lusmagh v Shamrocks at Banagher at 7.30pm - Shamrocks by 3 points
Sunday 28th: Ballinamere v Carrig & Riverstown at Kinnitty at 12 noon - Draw Match
Sunday 28th July: Drumcullen v Tullamore at Kilcormac at 6.30pm - Tullamore by 3 points
Tuesday 24th July: Tullamore v Ballinamere at Bórd na Móna Park at 7.30pm - Tullamore by 5 points
Tuesday 24th July: Brosna Gaels v Drumcullen at KIlcormac at 7.30pm - Brosna Gaels by 3 points
Saturday 28th July: Clodiagh Gaels v Brosna Gaels at Clara at 7.30pm - Brosna Gaels by 1 point
Saturday 28th July: Lusmagh v Shamrocks at Banagher at 7.30pm - Shamrocks by 3 points
Sunday 28th: Ballinamere v Carrig & Riverstown at Kinnitty at 12 noon - Draw Match
Sunday 28th July: Drumcullen v Tullamore at Kilcormac at 6.30pm - Tullamore by 3 points
Last edited by chimbonda on Thu Jul 26, 2018 2:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- All Star
- Posts: 442
- Joined: Tue Mar 04, 2014 12:09 pm
- Club: town
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
Tullamore and Ballinamere drew last night. 3 draws from the last 3 games for Ballinamere and only lost by 1 point in first game.
huge win for the sash lat night. Have a tough game at the weekend.
Saturday 28th July: Clodiagh Gaels v Brosna Gaels at Clara at 7.30pm -Clodiagh Gaels by 3 points.
Saturday 28th July: Lusmagh v Shamrocks at Banagher at 7.30pm - Lusmagh by 3 points
Sunday 28th: Ballinamere v Carrig & Riverstown at Kinnitty at 12 noon - Ballinamere by 6 points.
Sunday 28th July: Drumcullen v Tullamore at Kilcormac at 6.30pm - Tullamore by 4 points
huge win for the sash lat night. Have a tough game at the weekend.
Saturday 28th July: Clodiagh Gaels v Brosna Gaels at Clara at 7.30pm -Clodiagh Gaels by 3 points.
Saturday 28th July: Lusmagh v Shamrocks at Banagher at 7.30pm - Lusmagh by 3 points
Sunday 28th: Ballinamere v Carrig & Riverstown at Kinnitty at 12 noon - Ballinamere by 6 points.
Sunday 28th July: Drumcullen v Tullamore at Kilcormac at 6.30pm - Tullamore by 4 points
-
- All Star
- Posts: 1126
- Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 4:09 pm
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
Wins for lusmagh by 3 and clodiagh gaels by 9 points.
-
- All Star
- Posts: 1223
- Joined: Sun Jul 13, 2008 10:00 pm
Re: Senior B Hurling 2018
Does anyone have a points table for the SHCB championship, ?private joker wrote:Wins for lusmagh by 3 and clodiagh gaels by 9 points.