Posted: Tue Nov 14, 2006 11:25 am
I agree in that I don't think the Offaly vs Kilkenny thing will really be a factor here, Birr are a completely different entity certainly and fear will not be the problem with them.
I do think hurling might. That's not to knock Birr, but if Kilkenny people are to be believed (and even allowing for a little bit of hype here) this is the greatest club side to come out of Catland since, well, Ballyhale back around the late seventies and early eighties. And Birr have not exactly demonstrated that they're back to their best getting this far either. I don't doubt that the Coolderry games will be good for them, but an All Ireland standard team would have crossed that hurdle a lot easier - ditto they made life hard for themselves against Craobh last Sunday, a team with very small representation on the Dublin senior hurling panel.
I think Offaly hurling is somewhat similar to Offaly football at the moment in that we're not hugely endowed with players who love high ball in on top of their heads. This is where I fear for Birr in particular. Lads like Kevin Brady and Niall Claffey have looked like great ball winners in Offaly club games because they're not competing with much - well here Birr will be competing with a lot more aerial ability than they have so far, and I think it'll hurt them. They're used to their half back line dominating, even in close games, and in the absence of that they might struggle.
Regarding throwing in the towel, I don't expect anything like that. I do expect them to compete up to the last minute, but you can compete all you like, when you're up against a better team there's often nowhere to go.
I do think hurling might. That's not to knock Birr, but if Kilkenny people are to be believed (and even allowing for a little bit of hype here) this is the greatest club side to come out of Catland since, well, Ballyhale back around the late seventies and early eighties. And Birr have not exactly demonstrated that they're back to their best getting this far either. I don't doubt that the Coolderry games will be good for them, but an All Ireland standard team would have crossed that hurdle a lot easier - ditto they made life hard for themselves against Craobh last Sunday, a team with very small representation on the Dublin senior hurling panel.
I think Offaly hurling is somewhat similar to Offaly football at the moment in that we're not hugely endowed with players who love high ball in on top of their heads. This is where I fear for Birr in particular. Lads like Kevin Brady and Niall Claffey have looked like great ball winners in Offaly club games because they're not competing with much - well here Birr will be competing with a lot more aerial ability than they have so far, and I think it'll hurt them. They're used to their half back line dominating, even in close games, and in the absence of that they might struggle.
Regarding throwing in the towel, I don't expect anything like that. I do expect them to compete up to the last minute, but you can compete all you like, when you're up against a better team there's often nowhere to go.